A Quebec perspective on Driver Inc.
Before 1998, things were embarrassing for the trucking industry. There were poorly maintained, dangerous trucks. There was no framework requiring owners and operators of heavy vehicles to comply with regulatory standards or face the risk of banned from operating.
Then came Bill 430, a direct consequence of the bus accident that killed 44 people in Les Éboulements, Que., in 1997. This law put mechanisms in place and gave the Commission des transports du Québec the power to get offenders off the road.

It didn’t take long for fleets to appear that were rejuvenated, trucks that were more orderly. In very little time, a business registry and an effective control system with teeth capable of shredding a trucking company’s right to operate had been set up. It was capable of imposing a penalty that hurts, not a ridiculous fine.
Twenty-six years later, it’s more embarrassing than ever in the trucking industry, but for different reasons. We hear about accidents involving unregistered and uninsured trucks. Hundreds of thousands of dollars in tow bills that never get paid. Truckers literally running away after “tipping” a truck on the highway. Driving schools taking bribes to issue Class 1 licences and listing false driving experience on drivers’ records.
It feels like the Wild West with cowboys who don’t give a damn about anything. We’ve gone back in time with new delinquents to the power of 10 who transport at a discount and illegally, those we in Quebec call Chauffeurs Inc., a misclassification scheme by unscrupulous companies that evade taxes. The pirates of modern times.
Is this really the world we’re living in now? What’s going on?
Year after year, successive governments have let things get worse. We published our first article on the subject in 2013 and, since then, the scheme has spread, crossing the borders of Ontario and invading Quebec, from Lac-Saint-Jean to the Gaspé Peninsula, transporting at a discount the cargo formerly hauled by trucking companies that pay their payroll taxes, insurance and income taxes.
Who are the shippers who hire them, happy to save on their delinquent transport while gargling environmental, social and governance virtues in their annual reports? Do they even know to whom they entrust their goods?
Anything that hangs around gets dirty, and the Chauffeurs Inc. scheme has been going on for a ridiculously long time. It’s spreading everywhere and faster than ever. It’s causing phenomenal economic harm to legitimate transportation companies, but also to all taxpayers – we’re talking billions of dollars in unpaid payroll taxes. And it’s causing enormous harm to safety with its fake licences and uninsured trucks.
Government after government has been watching this go on without saying anything for 11 years. Even if government bodies say that things are moving forward, well, they are not moving forward.
It is time to call for a commission of inquiry into the trucking industry, as has been done in other industries, such as construction. It is time to expose to the public the corrupt situation that prevails in the industry, a situation that costs it billions and threatens its security. It is time to call to testify the actors and victims of this scheme, including shippers.
It’s time to clean up.
Have your say
This is a moderated forum. Comments will no longer be published unless they are accompanied by a first and last name and a verifiable email address. (Today's Trucking will not publish or share the email address.) Profane language and content deemed to be libelous, racist, or threatening in nature will not be published under any circumstances.
Sad thing is No one cares. We need someone who is important to be wiped out by our new TRUCKER, then they will see the light and stop calling us racist for complaining.
Well said I have been pushing for this since speed limiters came into ont. Driver inc in my opinion is not our biggest concern but part of many issues
In Ontario the numbers of foreign students and people born here that bought drivers permits has caused a insurance nightmare in.my opinion
The gov needs to allow gov insurance from.MB sask and B C to sell insurance to those trucking companies in ont that pay drivers on payroll a certain amount per hour and have a good training program and agree not to haul any freight under $2 cd per mile We need a complete investigation into how driver inc got so Big among T F Ws in Ontario and Quebec. Some major players in the trucking industry will push back against gov oversight and tell you the same as they did me that we want to become Cuba. At this time with the rates I see some of these driver inc companies hauling for that bring foreign people as students working foreign recruiting agencies that charge them $25000 to $45000 for a permit and a job at half the rate that Costco or Walmart pay a U S based drivers. It ( the ratess so low) that good small trucking companies and owner ops are forced to quit and be replaced with people who often are not trained or care about safety in.my opinion
Things only get looked at in a knee jerk reaction to something. The tragic Humboldt crash led to MELT but that good idea went south in a hurry.
Schools, and I use that term loosely, forging class and test results. Offering a licence for half of what a reputable school charges, kick backs to examiners. It has only gotten worse and just a handful of inspectors to regulate everything.
When the next big crash occurs, and it will, only then will the itch get scratched.
Steve,
what a well written and thoughtful but also a provocative article.
The real issue is two fold in my opinion, both the shippers and the unscrupulous trucking companies employing non qualified drivers for ridiculous rate while trying to repay the loans that afforded them to come to Canada in the first place.
Legitimate carriers that follow the law pay their taxes hopefully have strong enough customer relationships beyond just a cheap rate.
Safety is the number one priority not only for the carrier and its drivers but also for the shipper to ensure their shipment of goods arrive on time and safely intact.
Until the government gets at the root cause of the issue instead of chasing a group of ethnic votes I think we are in for more bad behaviour.
But bravo to you for once more bringing the problem to the problem.
Very good message Steve.
Therés two ways to solve ;
-1-get back to 70’s with la commission des transport who oblige shipper to paid thé righ Price, and push out the big shippers lobbyist : from 80’s they pluck thé chicken and now continu epilating it !
Or
-2-give thé controle of la commission des transports to trues peoples from all size carriers , peoples who wants and need carriers efficiency, Financial health and safety .
Great article, the bad players are slowly dying we hope. After the bankruptcy of a large corporation which stole their clients money recently emerged with the logistics and trucking business intact – that decision impacts everyone in the industry. Driver Inc continues to be the biggest blight for transportation Canada wide. I fear we haven’t reached the bottom of the lowest common denominator yet.
Definitely time to clean things up. Private auditor needs to investigate all aspects of the transport industry. This transport minister and previous need to take accountability for this gong show. Once again the people effected most are the “tax payers”.
Man, the corruption now is mind blowing
Well said Steve. In addition to the many good points you made we shouldn’t forget to mention that the Driver Inc. model was all but sanctioned by Justin Trudeau and Jagmeet Singh when the federal labour minister met with the trucking association representing the perpetrators of Driver Inc. and as reported in this paper had the nerve to apologize for the use of the term Driver Inc. because they claimed to find it offensive. Thank you for shining a light on the unscrupulous shippers that have no regard for the business practices of the carriers they choose and are more interested in cheap rates than good service or the safety of the motoring public. You forgot to mention the far bigger group that enables this unscrupulous bunch of offenders. The carriers and 3PL providers that have developed and expanded their 3PL operations so that they can quote cheap rates and pimp the freight out to the very group of scoundrels they have the audacity to complain about. You don’t have to be a mathematician to figure out that if there is a carrier out there that can provide the same service as you can but at half the cost you can with your own fleet, they are not operating with the same commitment to a high standard of operational ethics and saftey. Perhaps there needs to be some accountability tied back the owner of the trailer that is utilizing the services of a less that scrupulous “tractor service” as well as the shipper of the goods in that trailer? In a word, accountability is what is missing in the current equation. The last thing our industry needs is more regulation. The shortest route to correction is the enforcement of the rules we have that work, the adjustment or abolishment of the ones that don’t and most importantly, accountability.
i been driving for over 50 years i have never seen it so bad and dangerious on our highways so many dont have licences and no one seem to care most of them drivers are not employess they class themself as companies so the dont pay taxes it is not the same job as when i started
Hi Steve.
Well-written article, I’m 100% in agreement.