Manitoba truck-bus crash leaves at least 15 dead, echoes Humboldt tragedy

by The Canadian Press

A day trip to the casino for a busload of seniors turned to devastation Thursday after a fiery crash with a tractor-trailer on the Trans-Canada Highway west of Winnipeg. Fifteen people were killed and 10 sent to hospital.

Witnesses recounted rescue workers frantically pulling people from the burning bus near a partially jackknifed truck — its front end crumpled and smashed — amid broken glass, a large bumper, and what appeared to be a walker.

The injured suffered mainly head and orthopedic injuries, RCMP said, and both drivers survived.

Day&Ross, whose tractor-trailer was involved in the collision, said in a statement it was heartbroken about the crash but had limited details about what happened.

“We are holding out hope that those injured will recover,” said fleet CEO William Doherty. “We will fully co-operate with the investigation and offer any assistance and support that we can.”

RCMP cruiser
(File photo: istock)

Humboldt comparisons

The scope of the crash and location in a prairie province draws comparisons to a 2018 collision on a Saskatchewan highway, when a tractor-trailer ran through a stop sign at a rural intersection and collided with a bus carrying the Humboldt Broncos junior hockey team. Sixteen were killed and 13 injured.

That crash became a touchstone for regulators during the rollout of mandatory entry-level training regimes for new truck drivers and federally mandated electronic logging devices.

“This is a day in Manitoba and across Canada that will be remembered as one of tragedy and incredible sadness,” Assistant Commissioner Rob Hill, commanding officer of Manitoba’s RCMP, said of Thursday’s crash.

“To all those waiting (for information), I can’t imagine how difficult it is not knowing if the person you love the most will be making it home tonight.”

Clear conditions

Officials said 12 ambulances responded along with air support to the crash, which occurred in clear weather conditions at about noon at the intersection of the Trans-Canada Highway and Highway 5, just north of the town of Carberry.

Carberry is 170 kilometres west of Winnipeg and about halfway between Winnipeg and the Saskatchewan boundary.

RCMP Supt. Rob Lasson said it appears the bus, carrying 25 people from Dauphin and the surrounding area, was crossing the Trans-Canada, heading south on Highway 5, when it was struck.

“The bus had already crossed the westbound lanes and was crossing the eastbound lanes when it was struck by the semi,” said Lasson.

“Immediately, it became apparent that this was a mass casualty situation.”

Lasson declined to speculate on the cause or circumstances of the crash, but said the investigation continues and criminal charges are a possibility.

“(Further) answers will take some time.”

On the scene

Nirmesh Vadera, who was working at a business on the side of the highway when the crash happened, said he went outside and saw a truck with a smashed front end. 

A bus was on fire in the grass on the side of the road. First responders were trying to get people out of the burning vehicle, he said.

“It was burning and all the (firefighters) and medical help and everybody was trying to get them away from the fire. They were just trying to give treatment and everything,” he said.

Michael Stewart was driving nearby when he saw smoke in the distance and flashing lights. As he got closer, the horrific scene became clear.

“I then saw the emergency vehicles and the semi partially jackknifed with front of the cab smashed,” Stewart said in a message online. 

“Then I saw the bodies (lying) on the median.”

Messages and support

Lasson said investigators have already reached out to Saskatchewan peers who gained experience during the Humboldt crash.

“We have already linked into the investigators in Saskatchewan, who have firsthand experience and are some of the primary investigators in the investigation with the Humboldt crash,” he said.

The Broncos hockey team reached out on Twitter saying, “We are devastated to learn of the tragic news coming from Carberry.”

“Our thoughts and prayers are with everyone involved and affected.”

Other messages of condolence and support poured in from across the country.

“On behalf of the Manitoba Trucking Association, I would like to express condolences to those affected by today’s tragic accident and loss of life near Carberry. Our deepest sympathies are with those impacted, their families, and emergency personnel at the scene,” Manitoba Trucking Association executive director Aaron Dolyniuk said in an emailed statement.

“On behalf of its 5,000 members, CTA sends our deepest condolences to all those who lost their loved ones in today’s tragic collision in Manitoba. We are praying for a full recovery of those in the hospital, and we send our thoughts and prayers to the families affected,” the Canadian Trucking Alliance said on Twitter.

“My heart breaks hearing the news of the tragic accident near Carberry,” Manitoba Premier Heather Stefanson posted on social media. “My most sincere condolences go out to all those involved.”

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, on Twitter, called the news was “incredibly tragic.”

“I’m sending my deepest condolences to those who lost loved ones today, and I’m keeping the injured in my thoughts,” he said.

“I cannot imagine the pain those affected are feeling — but Canadians are here for you.”

  • With files from Today’s Trucking


Have your say


This is a moderated forum. Comments will no longer be published unless they are accompanied by a first and last name and a verifiable email address. (Today's Trucking will not publish or share the email address.) Profane language and content deemed to be libelous, racist, or threatening in nature will not be published under any circumstances.

*

  • Doesn’t matter who was at fault right now. I wish a full recovery to the injured, peace to those lost and strength to their families.
    Hopefully, this will be the last incident of its kind in Canada.

    • Several changes need to be made including giving drivers more time to deliver loads and more coaching of new young and foreign truck and bus drivers.

  • We need a better system of training and we need min wage rates with overtime pay and older safe drivers to coach younger and foreign new drivers. I have seen many crashes
    Each one accident is bad I feel for the families of the injured or expired
    We need to do away with large late delivery fees

  • As a long haul trucker I am deeply saddened by this tragic event. Humboldt revisited. But unless it can be ascertained that the trucker was distracted driving, on cellphone or texting, to me it’s obvious that the bus driver is at fault.

  • When will the government upgrade driver training as a trade like others, innocent people are being killed on a regular basis in Canada by unskilled commercial drivers?

    • In ont many of the disabled bus and van transport drivers are volunteers like myself and if paid are only part time at less than $20 CD per hour so the best go to other things . We need to look for some solutions

  • Well from what’s reported here in this article (yet to be verified) that the bis was crossing a major highway abd had crossed some lanes already so initially it may seem the the bus could have been in the wrong (inaccurately, and unsafely crossing a highway).
    Remains to be seen however. If a semi is on a highway with no obstructions such as controlled intersections it would be taken that the semi (no matter what’s ahead of it) would have the right of way. But of course this Era of supposedly “no fault garbage” the blame/fault will or may be place inaccurately on the wrong individual.
    Statistics in my opinion are rarely accurate as they can be calculated/mitigated in whichever direction one wishes with selected skewed/created data input.