Peace Bridge War Threatens to Ruin Border Improvements

FORT ERIE, ON. — The New York State Legislature has moved to dissolve the bi-national Peace Bridge Authority, a move that the Ontario Trucking Association (OTA) is saying will stall progress on key infrastructure improvements at the border crossing.

”Did anyone tell these people the War of 1812 is over?” OTA President David Bradley asks.

The Peace Bridge Authority (PBA), which consists of five Canadian and five American members, has had its share of internal conflicts that have recently spilled over into the public sphere.

Blame Game

According to various media reports, the last few months have seen New York politicians accusing Canadian PBA members of stalling progress towards the building of a new plaza on the U.S. side.

“That progress is in jeopardy due to lack of co-operation from the Canadian members of the PBA board,” wrote New York’s Director of State Operations Howard Glaser to Minister of Transport, Infrastructure and Communities Denis Lebel.

Transport Canada’s assistant deputy minister Scott Streiner responded to Glasner in a letter, saying that it wasn’t Canadian PBA members obstructing progress but rather “a lengthy environmental assessment process that was managed by the Federal Highway Administration and terminated by the State of New York after approximately 10 years. ” Streiner added that it was Canada’s understanding that the PBA had no authority to purchase lands or undertake other related projects until that assessment was completed. These are issues that had “nothing to do with Canadian law or Canadian representation on the PBA.”

Steiner goes on to write that the introduction of the bill to dissolve the PBA has created a “climate of doubt” that will only serve “as a distraction and compromise the ability to move ahead on the approved capital projects.”

The bill passed the legislature 92-49, and a whooping 61-0 in the Senate. All that remains is for New York Governor Andrew Cuomo to sign the bill into law.

Pay-back’s a Congested Border

According to the Niagara Falls Review, paraphrasing the board’s chairman Anthony Annunziata, “the authority would remain until 2020, but effective July 2014 wouldn’t have the ability to manage the long-term affairs of the Peace Bridge as it would have to sell off around $38 million worth of bonds.”

The OTA noted that “in 2012 the Peace Bridge Authority’s board approved a $50 million capital plan to improve the U.S. plaza that includes a new customs commercial building, the widening of approach lanes and improved access to I-190. Dissolution of the Peace Bridge Authority would force the pay-back of any outstanding bonds and would eliminate the funding needed to move forward with projects important to alleviating congestion and improving customs clearance processes.”

However, there’s speculation that New York cannot unilaterally and legally dissolve the 90-year old Canada-U.S. partnership. “Canada’s view is that significant amendments to the governance of the PBA cannot be made without the consent of both federal governments,” wrote Steiner in his response to Glaser.

But as it stands now, any planned infrastructure improvements at Canada’s second largest border is up in the air.

“Dissolving the Peace Bridge Authority seems to be an extreme way of resolving differences,” summed up Bradley.

Have your say

This is a moderated forum. Comments will no longer be published unless they are accompanied by a first and last name and a verifiable email address. (Today's Trucking will not publish or share the email address.) Profane language and content deemed to be libelous, racist, or threatening in nature will not be published under any circumstances.