Supervisor gets five years in prison for dump truck driver’s death

by Today's Trucking

A judge in a Barrie, Ont., court has sentenced a trucking company manager and truck owner to five years in prison for the death of a dump truck driver in 2020.

Milton Urgiles, 48, of Etobicoke was sentenced Feb. 18, according to an Ontario Provincial Police news release.

Urgiles was convicted of criminal negligence causing the death of the dump truck driver who worked for Urgiles the day his tire blew, and the truck crashed into a ditch south of Alliston, CTV reported.

justice
(Photo: iStock)

Denis Garant, 53, was killed instantly. He was a husband and father to a young boy. His widow’s victim impact statement described being traumatized and left in financial peril.

The crash investigation found that the supervisor and manager of the company who owned the CVOR for the involved commercial vehicle, failed to properly maintain the truck, resulting in a mechanical failure that ultimately lead to the collision.

Driver concerned about steering issue

Urgiles was found to have ignored Garant’s text the night before the fatal crash expressing his concern about an issue with the dump truck’s steering, according to CTV. Urgiles testified he checked the vehicle and shifted the blame to driver error.

The judge noted that if a mechanic had inspected the truck it wouldn’t have been on the road that day, adding “the collision would not have happened.”

An expert witness previously told the court there was an alignment issue with the truck and it should not have been on the road based on the poor condition of the tire. The expert said there wasn’t enough structural support in the weakened tire to sustain an impact.


Have your say


This is a moderated forum. Comments will no longer be published unless they are accompanied by a first and last name and a verifiable email address. (Today's Trucking will not publish or share the email address.) Profane language and content deemed to be libelous, racist, or threatening in nature will not be published under any circumstances.

*

  • I agree it in my opinion it should be 10 years in a prison labour camp working 60 hours per week
    This should become the standard and many owners and managers go to jail when things like this happen across Canada. Also when a distribution centers send a empty truck in a storm or the drivers with no hours and someone is hurt both the managers and security people should get a min 1 yr if someone hurt or over 100 000 damage and 9 years that can reduce to 5 yrs with good behavior in my opinion.

    Reply

  • Proper maintenance on all commercial equipment is a must. For the safety of the drivers and most importantly the public I have run my own commercial trucking business for quite a few years If your equipment is not maintained I personally take that equipment off the schedule. I am in a law suit because of my decision and will stand by it no matter what takes place.

    Reply