Truckers have cleaner records than many other working drivers: report

by Today's Trucking

TORONTO, Ont. – Truck drivers in the U.S. appear to have cleaner driving records than workers in other driving-related roles, according to an analysis of 2.5 million car insurance applications.

But the employees in one job category still fared a little better on average.

The results published by Insurify identified those who had one recorded violation in the last seven years.

On average, 26.53% of drivers across all occupations recorded a prior incident within the time window, while 26.8% of those with driving-related jobs reported an incident.

Bus drivers tended to have the cleanest records, with just under 20% (19.97%) recording a violation in the seven-year period. Truck drivers placed a close second, with 22.86% recording a prior violation. And 25.51% of postal workers had reported a prior incident.

About one in three (32.46%) of delivery people, while cited as “some of the emergent heroes of the pandemic”, had a prior violation.

“Perhaps given the pressing demand and relatively minimal requirements to become a delivery worker, drivers with this occupation have some of the least-clean driving records with an incident rate 19% above average,” Insurify concluded.

Taxi and limo drivers reported an incident rate that was 15% higher than the national average, with 30.93% recording a prior violation.

Valet drivers had a violation rate 10% higher than the national average, at 29.2%.

“While pay is not significantly correlated with the cleanliness of a driving record, the jobs at the top of the list do have overall higher annual wages than those at the bottom,” Insurify said

“The top two driving jobs with the cleanest records earn annual wages higher than US $45,000, while the bottom three earn less than $33,000. This trend suggests that employees who earn more, and therefore may feel more valued and supported by their employer, exhibit higher integrity on the road.”

Driving jobs with the best records tended to be involved in public service sectors such as public transportation and postal workers.

Have your say

This is a moderated forum. Comments will no longer be published unless they are accompanied by a first and last name and a verifiable email address. (Today's Trucking will not publish or share the email address.) Profane language and content deemed to be libelous, racist, or threatening in nature will not be published under any circumstances.


  • I got nailed allegedly doing 117km in a 105km governed truck with a 40000 pound load in Quebec. I wasn’t changing lanes or passing anyone.

    I had a 40 year clean record with no accidents or tickets or any lost demerit points until now. Now I have to arrange an eye test, write the exam and schedule a road test because I am 65. Fail any and I lose my job and everything I have worked for. The Ministry didn’t care about my clean record and are treating me like I am a stunt driver

    Funny how in Quebec, it seems to me every truck stopped by police seems to be from Ontario while Quebec registered trucks pass you like you’re sitting still.

    I was told I could take3 days to fight the charge but would probably lose anyway.
    If I had known what was in store, I would have tried to fight it.