BURLINGTON, Ont. – Animal rights activist Regan Russell died in a June 19 accident, protesting the very Ontario law that aims to discourage people from approaching livestock-hauling trucks and processing facilities.
It wasn’t the first time that protesters had gathered outside Fearman’s Pork to “bear witness” to pigs being transported to slaughter. Supporters of organizations such as Toronto Pig Save regularly walk up to such vehicles, extending water bottles out to pigs loaded in the trailers. But the accident happened a day after Ontario’s Security from Trespass and Protecting Food Safety Act was given royal assent.
It was also almost five years to the day after Toronto Pig Save co-founder Anita Krajnc was charged with criminal mischief for giving water to pigs being transported into the same facility in Burlington, Ont. She was later found not guilty.
“That area does see frequent plant protests,” Halton Regional Police Constable Steve Elms told Today’s Trucking.
Police continue to investigate video evidence relating to the June 19 accident, but no charges have been laid.
“This is a tragedy and we extend our sincere condolences to them,” facility owners Sofina Foods said in a public statement. “We also recognize the impact that this event had on our employees and have been providing support to them in these very difficult times.”
When introducing the legislation, the Ontario Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs cited concerns about people approaching moving trucks or attempting to stop the equipment on public roadways. Interacting with animals in transport would also cause additional stress to the livestock and risk introducing contaminants into the food supply, it added.
“The livestock trucking industry told us that it has challenges attracting drivers, and the additional challenge and stressor is the potential for danger to the drivers caused by those who interfere with the transport of farm animals or by those trying to interact with the farm animals while in transport,” a ministry spokeswoman told Today’s Trucking. “Livestock transport operators told us about incidents where people have stepped out in front of moving trucks, stopped trucks from gaining access to the processing plant, or harassed drivers. Those that approach moving trucks create safety risks for themselves, the drivers, and the animals being transported.”
The new rules prohibit stopping or interfering with motor vehicles transporting farm animals, or interacting with the farm animals without explicit prior consent. There are also several trespassing-related measures relating to farms and processing facilities themselves.
Penalties will include fines of up to $15,000 for a first offence and up to $25,000 for subsequent offences, compared to a maximum $10,000 fine under the Ontario Trespass to Property Act. Courts will also be able to order restitution for injury, loss or damages associated with the offence.
Protesters have come to refer to the legislation as the “ag gag” law.
Nearly 130 municipalities have passed or supported council resolutions looking for stronger protections for the related businesses. And about 5,000 letters have been submitted to support the legislation, the ministry says.
“We’ve urged [the government] to make this a priority because of the safety issues,” says Susan Fitzgerald, executive director of the Ontario Livestock Transporters’ Alliance, a group that she says represents 80% of commercial hog transportation in the province.
Fitzgerald expects the regulations to be enacted by this fall or early next year.
“Our concern has been with the protesters being up close to the trucks and trailers and the animals,” she says, referring to the protesters who approach loaded trailers, and the load security issues that can occur if the animals inside are spooked. “The drivers can’t see 360 degrees around the trailers.”
“Interfering with the operations of farms, food processing businesses, and livestock transporters not only puts the health and safety of our agri-food workers and farm animals at risk, but also jeopardizes our food safety,” Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs Minister Ernie Hardeman said last December, when introducing the legislation.
“Our concern has been with the protesters being up close to the trucks and trailers and the animals.”– Susan Fitzgerald, Ontario Livestock Transporters Alliance
“She [Russell] went that particular day to stand up for what she believed was the right for peaceful protests,” Krajnc says of the June 19 accident. “[Trucking operations] have safety protocols. You don’t plow into people.”
Several processing facilities have adjusted their procedures to allow for protests, Krajnc adds, using a Maple Leaf poultry facility as an example. Trucks there stop for five minutes before entering.
“You can create a culture of mutual respect where activists are able to protest peacefully.”
-This story has been updated to include comments from the Ontario Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs.
Have your say
This is a moderated forum. Comments will no longer be published unless they are accompanied by a first and last name and a verifiable email address. (Today's Trucking will not publish or share the email address.) Profane language and content deemed to be libelous, racist, or threatening in nature will not be published under any circumstances.