Truck crashes remain a cause of concern

by Abdul Latheef

TORONTO, Ont. – Ontario has made excellent progress on road safety over the past decade, but the top five problem areas, large truck crashes among them, remain a major concern, an official said Thursday.

Michael McGrath, safety research adviser at the Ontario Ministry of Transportation, told the Fleet Safety Council’s (FSC) provincial meeting that pedestrians, large trucks, impaired driving, unbelted occupants and speed contribute to a significant percentage of fatalities.

In 2017, the report said, crashes involving large trucks resulted in 141 deaths, accounting for 23% of all fatalities. (Photo: MTO)

In 2017, the last year for which confirmed figures are available, collisions involving large trucks resulted in 141 deaths, accounting for 23% of all fatalities, according to the Ontario Road Safety Annual Report (ORSAR) presented by McGrath at the meeting.

The preliminary report for 2018 shows fatalities falling to 95, or 15.5% of all deaths. The number rises again to 126 fatalities, or 23%, in the preliminary report for 2019, McGrath said.

The Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) reported in July that there were 8,432 crashes and 96 deaths involving large trucks in OPP patrolled areas alone.

That was the highest number of commercial vehicle collisions and fatalities in more than 20 years.

“One of the reasons why it takes so long to produce ORSAR is as a ministry, we review every single one of the traffic fatalities each year against records at the coroner’s office,” McGrath said.

“And, that review gives us really detailed information about the toxicology (of the crash victims)” he said.

Truck collisions remain a cause of concern. (Photo: iStock)

Are trucks at fault?

One of the attendees at the meeting asked whether it is fair to attribute so many collisions to trucks when a lot of them may have been caused by passenger vehicles.

Leanne Quail, operations manager at Paul Quail Transport of Alliston, Ont., said it bothers the industry when crashes are listed as “large truck collisions”.

“That is paining us as the only responsible one in this, whereas, public education on how to move around trucks safely is probably a huge factor that could change those numbers,” she said.

McGrath replied that when he was talking about the top five areas, he was not assigning a blame.

Often it is not the driver of the large truck who is found to be at fault in a collision, he said.

McGrath agreed that it is important to educate the general public about navigating around trucks safely.

Multiple studies in the U.S. in the past seven years have suggested that a majority of truck crashes are actually caused by cars.

McGrath also spoke about the mandatory entry-level training (MELT) program, which was introduced in Ontario in July 2017.

He said there is still no data on whether or not the introduction of MELT may have led to any sort of different driver behaviors.

Ontario has been among the Top 5 safest jurisdictions in North America for more than 20 years in a row. (Photo; iStock)

Ontario now safer

The number of licensed drivers in Ontario rose by more than 1 million between 2008 and 2017. The province now has over 10 million drivers.

McGrath said despite that surge as well as a big increase in the number of vehicles, fatalities has remained relatively consistent over the past 10 years

That means Ontario stacks up well against other places in the country and around the world. The province has been among the Top 5 safest jurisdictions in North America for more than 20 years in a row, he said.

Globally, Ontario is now ranked in the Top 10 list for road safety.

McGrath said that is significant because some of the countries at the top of the list such as Norway, Sweden and Denmark had implemented many of the safety measures Ontario enforced in recent years decades ago.

“So, we are going to watch these trends carefully over the next few years and see if some of these policies pay the same type of safety dividends that they paid in some of the Scandinavian countries,” he said.

Drug-involved driver fatalities among people 50 years and older doubled to more than 30% in 2017, the year before cannabis was legalized. (Photo: iStock)

Drug-involved fatalities

McGrath and his team have also been keeping a close eye on how the 2018 legalization of cannabis would affect driving behaviors.  

That was when they noticed something interesting.

In 2015, the drug-involved driver fatalities among people 50 years and older was below 16%.

But by 2017, that number had doubled to more than 30%.

“And, this is sort of interesting, especially from a public education standpoint, because there may be a common perception that drug involvement and collisions are something that young drivers or young people are engaged in,” McGrath said.

Have your say

This is a moderated forum. Comments will no longer be published unless they are accompanied by a first and last name and a verifiable email address. (Today's Trucking will not publish or share the email address.) Profane language and content deemed to be libelous, racist, or threatening in nature will not be published under any circumstances.


  • Under qualified truck drivers, distracted driving, and alcohol/drug impairment- resulting in countless fatalities and serious injuries.

    More disqualification of drivers and fleets is a definite start.

  • How about the Car Drivers, who cut Truck drivers off,,, and you refer to it as an accident involving a truck, being deceptive on the cause!!!!!!

  • I love our industry, it’s normal for a regular worker to do 8 hours at work, where are sure you’re not focused all the time behind your desk! But for us, it’s 14 hours long and 13 hours behind the wheels for driving a 72 ft long vehicle with no marge for an error, otherwise, we lost everything, our licence, our life and the blame should be for the new driver. Shame on you, maybe we should just re-organise everything don’t you think !!!!!